Jaylen Warren’s rise from undrafted free agent to the Pittsburgh Steelers’ lead running back is no fluke. His consistent performance over the past few seasons has convinced the Steelers to bet on him long-term despite drafting promising rookie Kaleb Johnson who's waiting in the wings.
Warren first signed with Pittsburgh in 2022 after going undrafted out of Oklahoma State. In his early seasons, he played a complementary role behind Najee Harris, contributing mainly in the passing game through blocking and receiving, while also flashing explosiveness on big plays — something the Steelers had been sorely lacking.
Despite limited opportunities, Warren has proven to be highly efficient, averaging approximately 4.8 yards per carry since entering the NFL, this being one of the best marks among running backs with similar volume. He’s never had more than 149 carries in a season, yet his ability to make plays both as a runner and receiver, coupled with his reliability in pass protection, has steadily built the coaching staff’s trust. Head coach Mike Tomlin’s no-nonsense, merit-based approach rewards production over pedigree and Warren embodies that philosophy.
A New Era in the Backfield
Entering the 2025 season, the Steelers’ backfield dynamic shifted dramatically with Najee Harris gone. It was somewhat surprising how easily Pittsburgh let Harris walk, but it speaks volumes about their confidence in Warren.
Concerns remain about whether he can handle a full workhorse load, but the Steelers don’t seem to need or want that from him. Instead, they plan to continue maximizing his touches efficiently — the same strategy that’s made him so effective. Warren is well-suited to be a 1A in a split backfield, with a capable 1B complementing his style.
Warren was retained as a restricted free agent on a one-year deal while the Steelers evaluated his readiness to lead. His strong production, attitude, and work ethic put him in prime position to take over.
Then, on September 1, 2025, Warren was rewarded with a two-year contract extension, keeping him in Pittsburgh through the 2027 season. The deal includes over $7 million in 2025 and around $12 million guaranteed — a clear indication of how much the organization values him both on and off the field. In an era when the running back market is being devalued, Warren’s average annual value ranks in the top 20 among NFL running backs.
This extension doesn’t mark the beginning of Warren’s proving ground, it’s confirmation that the Steelers already see him as the guy in their backfield. And with the contract structured to give him another shot at free agency in a couple of years, Warren still has plenty of motivation to elevate his game.
Enter Kaleb Johnson
The arrival of Kaleb Johnson, a third-round rookie out of Iowa, adds a layer of competition, but Warren has handled the challenge with confidence. Some speculated that Johnson’s selection would push Warren into the background. Instead, it seems the rookie was drafted to support Warren, not replace him.
Johnson brings size and a traditional downhill running style with fresh legs. However, his lack of experience and struggles in the passing game, particularly in protection and receiving, has put him behind Warren for now. Pass protection remains one of the most critical, and often overlooked, traits for NFL backs, and it's one area where Warren excels.
Warren has made it clear he’s focused on his own work, but he’s also embraced a leadership role, mentoring Johnson and helping him grow. In a locker room full of veterans, Warren’s background and underdog story give him a unique voice and he’s earning respect from teammates and coaches alike.
Eyes on the Prize
Warren’s job isn’t secure just because of his new contract. He still needs to produce every week — avoiding turnovers, making big plays, and remaining consistent with his preparation. With Johnson and Kenneth Gainwell behind him, the pressure is on. But that’s exactly the kind of environment where Warren thrives.
NFL coaches have always valued consistency. Them knowing exactly what they’ll get from a player in practice and on game day will always be of value no matter the team or coach. Warren’s steadiness hasn’t gone unnoticed. Beating out a former first-round pick like Harris — and others along the way — is proof of his value to the team.
More Than a Contract
Jaylen Warren has earned more than just a contract, he’s earned the lead role based on his proven track record. Even if some still doubt whether he can thrive in this position, Warren’s versatility, consistency, and experience give him the edge for now.
His story reflects a broader trend among Oklahoma State running backs who carve out roles in the NFL. From Chuba Hubbard to Justice Hill to Ollie Gordon, Mike Gundy’s program has instilled a mindset that translates to the pros. Warren is just the latest example of that toughness and drive.
As the Steelers move into the 2025 season, all eyes will be on Warren to see if he can continue delivering as the lead back — and whether Johnson can earn enough trust to share the spotlight.