When Oklahoma quarterback John Mateer went down with a broken hand late in their win over Auburn, most assumed he’d be sidelined for weeks. Surgery followed, and expectations were tempered: many believed a return in the month ahead was optimistic. Yet now whispers suggest Mateer may attempt a return, possibly as early as this weekend, in the Red River Rivalry against Texas. If true, that would be nothing short of remarkable.
For Oklahoma State fans, the situation brings mixed emotions. On one hand, watching a rival overcome adversity and rise again is undeniably compelling. On the other, it’s a bittersweet reality as this Oklahoma team continues to gain national attention and popularity as the season unfolds. The recruiting battle is already tilting in the Sooners' favor, and their resurgence only deepens the sting for Oklahoma State. While both Texas and Oklahoma have moved on from the Big 12, OSU fans still feel the weight of long-standing rivalries with both programs, making it a true double-edged sword when choosing who to root for in this matchup.
Injury Timeline & Recovery Expectations
Mateer sustained the injury to his right (throwing) hand during the first quarter of the Auburn game. Despite the pain, he continued to play, finishing the game and even delivering key plays. Soon after, Oklahoma opted for surgery to repair the damage. The initial prognosis estimated a recovery time of roughly one month — a timeline that would logically rule him out for the Texas matchup.
During Mateer’s recuperation period, the Sooners had the benefit of a bye week and an easier opponent in Kent State, which allowed backup Michael Hawkins Jr. to lead the offense without rushing the decision on Mateer’s return. Along the way, Oklahoma coaches and medical staff have remained cautious, noting his progress but not committing to a return date.
Recently, media sources have reported Mateer is “pushing” to return, though no official decision has been made. The post-surgery reports have been encouraging, and both Oklahoma and Texas coaches are preparing for the possibility of him playing. Texas, in particular, refuses to dismiss Mateer’s influence, choosing to game-plan as though he could take the field.
What It Would Mean if He Plays
If Mateer steps onto the field this weekend, it would instantly become one of the most talked-about comebacks of the season. It would underscore his toughness, his commitment to teammates, and his belief in leading through adversity. To contend with the injury, rehab, and pressure and then return in a rivalry game would only bolster his legacy at Oklahoma.
With Mateer back under center, the Longhorns would face a more dangerous version of the Sooners offense. His dual-threat capability, passing and running, transforms game planning. A healthy Mateer elevates Oklahoma’s chances, not just to win the Red River game, but to remain in the conversation for the College Football Playoff and a spot near the top of the SEC (or equivalent standings).
Legacy, Stakes & Risks
For Mateer, the stakes are huge. If he returns and leads Oklahoma past Texas, even in a limited capacity, it would boost his Heisman credentials and cement his name in Oklahoma lore — especially in a season he’s already excelled. But with so much riding on this return, the risk is equally large: pushing too soon could lead to setbacks or reinjury, and his performance under duress may not match expectations.
In the end, whether Mateer plays or not, the narrative is already rich. If he suits up, it could become one of the season’s defining moments — not just for Oklahoma football, but for the larger playoff and rivalry picture as Oklahoma State continues to lose ground on the In-State rivalry for turf wars.